Monday, January 4, 2021

Modi's Vaccine Nationalism: India's Hasty Approval of Homegrown COVID19 Vaccine

Indian drug regulator has approved COVAXIN, a Covid19 vaccine developed by Bharat Biotech.  The approval has been granted without completing large-scale phase 3 trials in India, according to media reports. It is India's first indigenous vaccine co-developed with Pennsylvania-based startup Ocugen. Ocugen, led by Indian-American scientists, does not currently sell any products.  India is the world's second worst-hit country by the global coronavirus pandemic.  Critics say the hasty approval of the homegrown Indian vaccine is motivated by "chest thumping nationalism". 

US-Based Ocugen: 

How COVAXIN Works. Source: NY Times

Ocugen is a US-based biotech company. It has no track record. It has not developed any drugs and doesn't have any products to sell yet. This lack of experience makes Ocugen a strange choice for an international commercialization partner, according to an investment analysis published in the United States. The Food and Drug Administration has made it clear that it won't authorize a coronavirus vaccine without data from a phase 3 trial conducted in the United States. NASDAQ-listed Ocugen stock has soared since the approval of COVAXIN for use in India. 

Bharat Biotech:

Bharat Biotech is an Indian biotechnology company based in the South Indian city of Hyderabad. 

Dr. Krishna Ella, the Chairman of the Bharat Biotech, has claimed that they are "no way" inferior to Pfizer in terms of coronavirus vaccine. He also said that Bharat Biotech is the only firm to have published five articles on the Covid-19 vaccine process, according to media reports

COVAXIN Vaccine: 

Some critics have dismissed COVAXIN approval as a manifestation of "chest thumping nationalism". Bloomberg's Andy Mukherjee has a story entitled "COVAXIN: Science, not pride will help India build trust in this vaccine". 

Indian government's decision to authorize COVAXIN has been sharply criticized by public interest groups in India. “The decision to approve an incompletely studied vaccine, even under accelerated process, raises more questions than answers and likely will not reinforce faith in our scientific decision-making bodies,” Malini Aisola, of the All India Drug Action Network (AIDAN), an independent collective of healthcare non-profits, said in a statement.

COVID19 Pandemic:

India has been hit hard by the coronavirus pandemic with over 10 million infections, second only to the United States. Indian economy has shrunk by double digits. Tens of millions of daily wage earners who make up the bulk of India's workforce have lost their livelihoods. Prime Minister Narendra's Modi's decision to impose a sudden nationwide lockdown is blamed for it. 

Summary:

COVAXIN is India's first indigenously developed vaccine that has just been approved for emergency use in the country. It has been co-developed with US-based Ocugen. COVAXIN's hasty approval without any phase 3 efficacy data has come under  sharp criticism. Some critics have dismissed COVAXIN approval as a manifestation of "chest thumping nationalism". Bloomberg's Andy Mukherjee has a story entitled "COVAXIN: Science, not pride will help India build trust in this vaccine". 

Related Links:

Haq's Musings

South Asia Investor Review

COVID19 in Pakistan: Test Positivity Rate and Deaths Declining

Turkish Muslims Behind Pfizer Vaccine

Construction Industry in Pakistan

Pakistan's Pharma Industry Among World's Fastest Growing

Pakistan to Become World's 6th Largest Cement Producer by 2030

Is Pakistan's Response to COVID19 Flawed?

Pakistan's Computer Services Exports Jump 26% Amid COVID19 Lockdown

Coronavirus, Lives and Livelihoods in Pakistan

Vast Majority of Pakistanis Support Imran Khan's Handling of Covid19 Crisis

Pakistani-American Woman Featured in Netflix Documentary "Pandemic"

Coronavirus Antibodies Testing in Pakistan

Can Pakistan Effectively Respond to Coronavirus Outbreak? 

How Grim is Pakistan's Social Sector Progress?

Pakistan Fares Marginally Better Than India On Disease Burdens

Trump Picks Muslim-American to Lead Vaccine Effort

Democracy vs Dictatorship in Pakistan

Pakistan Child Health Indicators

Pakistan's Balance of Payments Crisis

Panama Leaks in Pakistan

Conspiracy Theories About Pakistan Elections"

PTI Triumphs Over Corrupt Dynastic Political Parties

Riaz Haq's Youtube Channel

PakAlumni Social Network

24 comments:

Anonymous said...

Ocugen has no role in the development of covaxin.It is there for commercializing this vaccine in the US.

In any case what is Pakistan and the entire Sunni Islamic worlds vaccines..oh wait..In the entire Islamic world only Iran has a vaccine undergoing trials.Pathetic.

So since India can both produce(world champion) and develop covid vaccines including sophisticated mRNA vaccines look up Zycus Cadilla mRNA vaccine you are in absolutely no position to criticize.

This is the same lobby that tells poor countries not to build their industrial bases.Good that India unlike Pakistan never listened to them.

BTW when do you think Pakistan will be able to secure 200 million doses(2 doses per person Im assuming 100 million will have to be vaccinated)2023,2024?

Mayraj F. said...

Probably dangerous - polluted by jugaad

https://www.outlookindia.com/website/story/business-news-ranbaxy-and-the-culture-of-jugaad-what-brought-a-leading-company-down/340313
Ranbaxy And The Culture Of Jugaad: What Brought A Leading Company Down
With the arrest of Shivinder Singh and Malvinder Singh on a complaint by Religare Fininvest, the spotlight has once again fallen on the dealings by the two brothers

https://www.firstpost.com/business/fda-action-on-ranbaxy-whistleblower-says-indian-pharma-dependent-on-jugaad-1360469.html
FDA action on Ranbaxy: Whistleblower says Indian pharma relies on jugaad
What ails the Indian pharmaceutical industry that has resulted in action from the US FDA on multiple occasions?

https://www.aei.org/health-care/bottle-of-lies-katherine-eban-shows-the-fraud-behind-indias-drug-industry/
Bottle of Lies: Katherine Eban shows the fraud behind India’s drug industry
https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/the-indian-way-no-way/article4804513.ece
The Indian way? No way

Riaz Haq said...

Anonymous: "Ocugen has no role in the development of covaxin.It is there for commercializing this vaccine in the US"

Ocugen, a small company that has no products yet, is a strange choice for "commercializing" a vaccine in US, the world's biggest market.

Anon: " In any case what is Pakistan and the entire Sunni Islamic worlds vaccines..oh wait..In the entire Islamic world only Iran has a vaccine undergoing trials.Pathetic."

In case you don't know, the Pfizer vaccine was developed by a "Sunni Islamic" couple from Turkey.A lot more Muslims have so far been vaccinated than Hindus worldwide.


Anon: " BTW when do you think Pakistan will be able to secure 200 million doses(2 doses per person Im assuming 100 million will have to be vaccinated)2023,2024?"

Pakistan has already started vaccinating its population.

Read this: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/pakistan-coronavirus-vaccine/2020/12/31/b2582d5e-4843-11eb-a9f4-0e668b9772ba_story.html

And this: https://www.business-standard.com/article/current-affairs/pakistan-to-purchase-covid-19-vaccine-from-china-s-sinopharm-120123100641_1.html

Anonymous said...

Unlike Paki with no industrial capability India has an advanced pharmaceutical industry and is the world's largest producer of vaccines.

Riaz Haq said...

Anon: "Unlike Paki with no industrial capability India has an advanced pharmaceutical industry and is the world's largest producer of vaccines"

"Advanced pharmaceutical industry" in India? Are you serious? India makes generic copies of pharmaceuticals developed elsewhere. And over 90% of the active ingredients (API) used by Indian industry come from China. It's essentially a packaging and distribution operation.

Shams N. said...

So what's better - Modi's fast-release of the Indian made vaccine, or using your nation as a guinea pig for the CHinese vaccine

Riaz Haq said...

Shams: "So what's better - Modi's fast-release of the Indian made vaccine, or using your nation as a guinea pig for the CHinese vaccine"

Are we in America being used as guinea-pigs by Germans? Is that what the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine trial was about?

Boss said...

Start of the usual self-praise story. When Covid started their media was saying that India was managing the Pandemic better than even the European countries and then the $hit hit the fan with second highest infections and third highest deaths in the world. Now in their desire to show to the world how smart and developed they are in bio-technology they will start using a half baked vaccine and kill a few more thousand people. Other than the US, no country has mismanaged Covid more than India.

Shams N. said...

Clearly you lack the understanding of a valid eval process versus the Pakistanis being used as guinea pigs.

Pfizer went through the entire level 3 process using healthy volunteers.

Riaz Haq said...

Shams: "Pfizer went through the entire level 3 process using healthy volunteers"

You are parroting western bigotry against China.

Chinese and Pakistani processes are no different than the US process.

And Pakistanis are more sceptical of any vaccines than people elsewhere, including the US where the anti-vaccine movement is very strong.

Chinese vaccines have not received approval in Pakistan. It's pending phase 3 trial.

Indian COVAX vaccine was given approval by Modi without completing phase 3 trial.

Read this: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/pakistan-coronavirus-vaccine/2020/12/31/b2582d5e-4843-11eb-a9f4-0e668b9772ba_story.html

Mantou said...

"This is the same lobby that tells poor countries not to build their industrial bases."

Curious what industrial bases India has?

Anonymous said...

At a time when Covid cases & deaths are rapidly dwindling&sero surveys show that >15 Cr people in India have already been infected,& death rates are less than 1/1000, the Govt is rushing through vaccines which have not been properly tested. We saw the Noteban & Lockdown disasters

https://twitter.com/pbhushan1/status/1346106625690456064?s=20

Riaz Haq said...

India’s Vaccine Nationalism Is a Global Risk
By Andy Mukherjee | Bloomberg
Jan. 4, 2021 at 5:58 p.m. PST


https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/indias-vaccine-nationalism-is-a-global-risk/2021/01/04/17d4c946-4e50-11eb-a1f5-fdaf28cfca90_story.html



The hasty nod for Bharat Biotech International Ltd.’s Covaxin, developed in collaboration with the Indian Council of Medical Research and National Institute of Virology, has raised eyebrows in the scientific and healthcare communities about a “public rollout of an untested product,” according to a national network of nongovernment organizations.

This is unfortunate. With more than 10 million coronavirus infections, India is the world’s second-worst-affected nation after the U.S. New Delhi’s strategy for vaccinating 1.3 billion people will matter greatly for bringing the global pandemic to a decisive end. The country’s virus-battered economy and its overstretched health systems are also yearning for a reprieve. It will be dangerous to allow political calculations to enter the equation and shake people’s confidence in what’s being offered to them — and on what basis.


That’s just what seems to be happening with the unusual approval for Covaxin, which comes with the odd caveat that its use will be restricted to “public interest as an abundant precaution, in clinical trial mode, especially in the context of mutant strains.” Nobody seems to know what this will mean on the ground. Who’ll get Covishield, and who’ll be given Covaxin? More importantly, who’ll decide? In a country beset by massive inequalities in income, wealth and social status, these aren’t trivial questions.

When opposition leaders raised doubts about the vaccine selection process, a minister in Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s cabinet likened their objections to questioning “the valor of our soldiers.”

To be sure, India is not even in the front row of vaccine nationalism. China and Russia are more desperate to beat the West in saving the world. But as my colleague Clara Ferreira Marques has noted, both countries’ vaccine candidates face a transparency deficit, which could limit their global acceptance.


That’s a risk that India, which manufactures more than 60% of the world’s vaccines, should avoid at all cost. According to media reports, Hyderabad, India-based Bharat Biotech has enlisted 23,000 volunteers for phase three clinical trials. That’s encouraging because another report, published last month, had cited a major New Delhi-based research hospital as saying that it couldn’t find enough subjects for the study. If the drug proves to be effective, introducing it even at a later date should pose no problems. Naming Covaxin as an alternative even in the absence of phase three data could be a commercial tactic to squeeze “better discounts” on bulky Covishield purchase contracts, brokerage Jefferies says. Still, cutting corners with science isn’t exactly the best strategy to negotiate drug prices.

The Kremlin-backed Sputnik V is also undergoing trials in India, in partnership with local manufacturer Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories Ltd. The Ahmedabad-based Cadila Healthcare Ltd. is also in the race to develop an indigenous Covid-19 vaccine. Ultimately, it doesn’t matter whether India’s homegrown shots make the final cut. Serum Institute, the world’s largest producer, has already stockpiled 70 million doses of Covishield. Big parts of the developing world will rely on Indian manufacturers to supply easy-to-administer, affordably priced vaccines in large quantities.

Anonymous said...

Thank god India has it's own industry rather than.

I don't like the other Indian commenter's (and Riaz's) Hindu-Muslim-ization of the issue. It's quite disgusting and to think people living in the civilized world think like this is quite concerning.

The Turkish couple could only make the vaccine in Germany, not in Turkey.
The Oxford-Astrazeneca vaccine also had Indians (citizens - not origin) on the core dev team. Clearly both India and the Islamic world have problems retaining their talents, but India is making some progress in bringing people home. Krishna Ella is a wisconsin-madison PhD from the US who moved back to India.

Riaz is lying through his teeth when he tries to imply that Ocugen 'invented' the vaccine. It was invented in India by Indians - like many other vaccines. Bharat Biotech has the world's best typhoid vaccine right now.

As for shitting on India's pharma sector - Riaz sahib - India's annual pharma exports are as big as Pakistan's entire product exports. We produce more than 60% of the world's vaccines and anti-venoms - even Pakistan imports large amounts of APIs, anti-venoms from India, along with several vaccines and generics.

If you hate us so much - why don't you ask the Imran Khan government to ban pharma imports from India?

Anonymous said...


"Curious what industrial bases India has?"

Automobiles - world's 5th largest manufacturer, in motorcycles and scooters we actually dominate a lot of african, south east asian, and latin american markets - in many countries the auto-rickshaw is called 'bajaji' (named after Bajaj Motors)

Steel - world's 2nd largest producer

Smartphone Assembly - world's 2nd largest producer of smartphones

Pharmaceuticals - world's 3rd largest pharm producer by volume, and produces more than 60% of the entire world's vaccines.

Textiles - probably 3rd or 4th largest in the world - this sector is a disappointment though and probably going to decline further.

Wind Energy - Bharat Forge is one of the world's largest producers of wind power units

Oil Refining - India doesn't produce much oil but refines it for the majority of the middle east including countries as far as Venezuela. The Saudis sell us oil, we refine it and sell it to others. Reliance operates the world's largest

Space - India has one of the world's most competitive satellite launch sectors, which is a fast growing market - it's also the only non-western country with private space startups sending up satellites to space and building launch vehicles.

Defense - although a perennial disappointment, the defense sector has picked up recently with over $1.5B in exports last year apart from offsetting costs due to import substitution. India manufactures decent armored trucks, missile systems, attack helicopters, patrol boats and kevlar vests. The sector has been growing by a staggering 165% YOY CAGR. It will obviously slow down but still the signs are good.

America (Boeing) is manufacturing F-16 wings in India with Tata.
Russia is setting up Kalashnikov manufacturing in Uttar Pradesh, and scaling up missile research collaborations.
Israel IAI is making defense drones in India with Adani and missile defense systems in collaboration with DRDO.
Tonbo Systems (Indian startup by CMU-returned grad) - is selling AI-powered tactical recon gear to Israeli and US army.
Indian shipbuilding is making a major comeback (India used to be an exporter of wooden ships before the British came and wrecked that industry) with locally developed Aircraft Carriers and Nuclear Submarines coming into operation.

The future looks good for the defense sector, although it is much smaller than other countries of the same size.

Source: https://www.timesnownews.com/india/article/india-s-defence-exports-increase-by-700-in-two-years-ranks-19th-among-world-s-defence-exporters/650027

It's true that India has ignored the western world's advice on how to run its industry and is benefiting because of it - just like korea, china, malaysia, vietnam etc. Hope Riaz doesn't delete this comment.

Riaz Haq said...

#India #farmersrprotest | Farmer leaders reject Supreme Court panel as a ‘government ploy’ to reduce pressure on #Modi sarkar. #Sikh #Punjab https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/farm-leaders-disappointed-with-sc-directions/article33557805.ece

“We understand that this committee is a government ploy. It is only meant to divert attention from the protest, and to reduce the pressure on the government,” said Balbir Singh Rajewal, who heads his own faction of the Bharatiya Kisan Union in Punjab.

“All members of this committee are pro-government, and they have been promoting and justifying these laws from the beginning. They have been writing in the newspapers, claiming that these laws are in farmers’ interests,” he said.

One of the proposed committee members, food and agricultural policy expert Pramod Kumar Joshi, told The Hindu he had not yet received any official communication from the Supreme Court, and would not comment until he had seen the committee’s terms of reference. He has previously characterised the farmers’ repeal demand as “bizarre”. Another member, agricultural economist Ashok Gulati, has been a long-time advocate for farm reforms and welcomed the Centre’s announcement of the new laws as “big, bold steps in the right direction which will benefit both farmers and consumers”.

--------


The unions said they intend to show up for the next round of talks with Central Ministers led by Mr. Tomar, scheduled for January 15. In the meanwhile, a full calendar of protest events will continue, starting with plans to burn the three farm laws for the festival of Lohri on Wednesday, which will also mark the 50th day of protest on the borders of Delhi. Women, children and senior citizens will also continue to participate in the protest, despite the Chief Justice’s appeal to send them home.

With regard to their Republic Day plans, union leaders said the Centre was misleading the Supreme Court on the issue. “We are going to protest peacefully. We don’t want to occupy Parliament. We have no plan to go to Lal Qila. On our side, violence will not be tolerated,” said Mr. Rajewal, adding that the tractor parade would take place in Delhi as well as in other locations across the country.

Riaz Haq said...

#India #farmersrprotest | Farmer leaders reject Supreme Court panel as a ‘government ploy’ to reduce pressure on #Modi sarkar. #Sikh #Punjab https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/farm-leaders-disappointed-with-sc-directions/article33557805.ece

“We understand that this committee is a government ploy. It is only meant to divert attention from the protest, and to reduce the pressure on the government,” said Balbir Singh Rajewal, who heads his own faction of the Bharatiya Kisan Union in Punjab.

“All members of this committee are pro-government, and they have been promoting and justifying these laws from the beginning. They have been writing in the newspapers, claiming that these laws are in farmers’ interests,” he said.

One of the proposed committee members, food and agricultural policy expert Pramod Kumar Joshi, told The Hindu he had not yet received any official communication from the Supreme Court, and would not comment until he had seen the committee’s terms of reference. He has previously characterised the farmers’ repeal demand as “bizarre”. Another member, agricultural economist Ashok Gulati, has been a long-time advocate for farm reforms and welcomed the Centre’s announcement of the new laws as “big, bold steps in the right direction which will benefit both farmers and consumers”.

--------


The unions said they intend to show up for the next round of talks with Central Ministers led by Mr. Tomar, scheduled for January 15. In the meanwhile, a full calendar of protest events will continue, starting with plans to burn the three farm laws for the festival of Lohri on Wednesday, which will also mark the 50th day of protest on the borders of Delhi. Women, children and senior citizens will also continue to participate in the protest, despite the Chief Justice’s appeal to send them home.

With regard to their Republic Day plans, union leaders said the Centre was misleading the Supreme Court on the issue. “We are going to protest peacefully. We don’t want to occupy Parliament. We have no plan to go to Lal Qila. On our side, violence will not be tolerated,” said Mr. Rajewal, adding that the tractor parade would take place in Delhi as well as in other locations across the country.

Riaz Haq said...

Up to 1m #Hindus gather in #India as festival goes ahead amid #COVID19 fears. Millions more are expected to descend on Haridwar in the coming weeks for #KumbhMela2021, one of the world’s biggest religious gatherings. #Muslim #Hajj was canceled in 2020. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/14/hindus-gather-india-kumbh-mela-festival-covid-fears

Many religious gatherings across the world have been cancelled or scaled back because of Covid. Only a few thousand Muslims took part in last year’s hajj, the annual pilgrimage to Mecca, compared with more than 2 million in normal years.

The pope celebrated midnight mass on Christmas Eve with fewer than 100 participants instead of the usual 10,000. In nearly all countries, Christians, Muslims, Jews and those of other faiths have curtailed or cancelled events marking religious festivals in the past 10 months.

--------------

Most of those walking into the freezing river on Thursday morning were not wearing masks and social distancing was hard to maintain. Senthil Avoodai K Raj, a senior police official, said thousands of security forces were present and fines could be imposed for breaching Covid regulations.


India has recorded more than 10m Covid cases – the second highest number in the world after the US – and has recorded more than 150,000 deaths.

On Saturday, the government will launch a vaccination drive, aiming to inoculate 300 million people by early August. Healthcare and frontline workers will be vaccinated first, followed by people over 50 and those with underlying health conditions.

Some pilgrims in Haridwar dismissed the threat from the virus. “India is not like Europe … when it comes to immunity we are better,” said 50-year-old Sanjay Sharma. “It’s really sad to see people not gathering at Kumbh in the same numbers as they would earlier … The greatest truth on Earth is death. What’s the point of living with fear?”

Riaz Haq said...

#Pakistan approves #AstraZeneca #COVID #vaccine for emergency use, the first #coronavirus vaccine to get approval. Pak would get vaccine from multiple sources, including "tens of millions" of doses under an agreement with #China's CanSinoBio https://news.yahoo.com/astrazeneca-covid-vaccine-gets-approval-113332785.html?soc_src=social-sh&soc_trk=tw&tsrc=twtr via @YahooNews


AstraZeneca's COVID-19 vaccine has been approved for emergency use in Pakistan, the health minister said on Saturday, making it the first coronavirus vaccine to get the green light for use in the South Asian country.

Pakistan, which is seeing rising numbers of coronavirus infections, said its vaccines would be procured from multiple sources.

"DRAP granted emergency use authorisation to AstraZeneca's COVID vaccine," the health minister, Faisal Sultan, told Reuters.

Approval has been given to get more than a million doses of Sinopharm's vaccine from China, he said.

"We are in the process to obtain Western origin and other vaccines both via bilateral purchase agreements as well as via the COVAX facility," he said.

The Chinese vaccine is awaiting approval from the Drug Regulatory Authority of Pakistan (DRAP), which has received and reviewed its data.

Pakistan is speaking to a number of vaccine makers, and Sultan said the country could get "in the range of tens of millions" of vaccine doses under an agreement with China's CanSinoBio.

The vaccine company's Ad5-nCoV COVID-19 candidate is nearing completion of Phase III clinical trials in Pakistan.

Efficacy is a key factor, said Sultan. "We have and are watching the evolving stories around efficacy of a number of vaccines."

Sultan said preliminary results of the Cansino may come in by mid-February. He added that Pakistan was considering to engage with Russia's Sputnik V vaccine.

Pakistan reported 2,432 new coronavirus infections and 45 deaths on Friday, taking the total number of cases to more than 516,000 and deaths close to 11,000.

"Our aim is that the bulk of the population will be covered free," the minister said, adding that private sectors could also be allowed once supply was available to an authorized company.

Sultan added that Pakistan had adequate cold chain facilities for most kinds of vaccines.

Riaz Haq said...

Modi's vaccine nationalism is risking Indians' lives.

He approved a homegrown #COVID vaccine without phase 3 trials.

He has not taken this vaccine himself. Other world leaders have built confidence in their vaccines by getting vaccine shots on camera.

Riaz Haq said...

#Hindu Nationalists attack #AmazonPrime's "Tandav" episode which shows #farmersrprotest & student protests and police killings that have happened in recent months under #Modi. Its title “Dictator” is apparent reference to Modi. #BJP #Hindutva #FreeSpeech https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/18/business/india-amazon-tandav.html

Bollywood once again has fallen into the cross hairs of India’s Hindu nationalist ruling party — and major Western streaming services like Amazon and Netflix increasingly find themselves caught in the middle.

Two separate criminal complaints were filed with the police over the weekend against the makers of “Tandav,” a splashy new big-budget web series on Amazon. The fast-paced political drama, which seems to borrow heavily from India’s political scene, may cut uncomfortably close to current events and the country’s biggest controversies.

The complainants, which include a politician with the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party, have insisted that the government pull the series off the air or take out key scenes. Among other objections, they accused the series of disrespecting Hindu gods, belittling members of individual castes and sullying the office of the prime minister.

If the police find merit to the complaints, Amazon and the show’s promoters could wind up in criminal court.

Ali Abbas Zafar, the director of “Tandav,” on Monday posted a statement on his Instagram account saying the show “is a work of fiction and any resemblance to acts and persons and events is purely coincidental.” However, the statement said, the cast and crew “take cognizance of the concerns expressed by the people and unconditionally apologize if it has unintentionally hurt anybody’s sentiments.”

Officials at Amazon have declined to comment.

Defenders of the show say those complaints are pretexts. The pressure on Amazon to drop the series, they say, is part of an increasingly intolerant atmosphere in India that affects even Bollywood, India’s film and entertainment industry. Actors, comedians, producers, artists and anyone who dares to question the government, even indirectly, can find their careers in peril, they say.

“When you take a stand, you have to pay a price,” said Sushant Singh, a Bollywood actor who has openly campaigned against several of the government’s policies. “One doesn’t even get surprised these days. And one does not know how to react anymore.”

These attitudes complicate the ambitions of both Bollywood studios and major companies to capture a huge Indian audience through their laptops and smartphones. Like the Hollywood film industry, Bollywood has increasingly turned to streaming as pandemic restrictions slam the theater business.

Riaz Haq said...

#Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi Speaks with #Pakistani Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi on the Phone. #Beijing has decided to assist Pakistan with #Covid19 #vaccine and coordinating with Chinese enterprises to accelerate its export to Pakistan

https://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/zxxx_662805/t1847949.shtml

Wang Yi said that fighting the pandemic is a top priority for the international community. President Xi Jinping has repeatedly said that the Chinese COVID-19 vaccines, once developed and put into use, will be global public goods. China has not only made promises, but also taken concrete actions to fulfill them by vigorously promoting vaccine cooperation with other countries, in particular, offering assistance and support to developing countries. Pakistan is China's all-weather strategic cooperative partner, and the two sides enjoy a fine tradition of supporting and helping each other. When one side is in trouble, the other side will always lend a helping hand without hesitation. The Chinese government has decided to assist the Pakistani side on vaccine and actively coordinated with Chinese enterprises to accelerate the export of vaccines to Pakistan. Our phone conversation today and the vaccine cooperation between China and Pakistan will unveil the beginning of the celebration of the 70th anniversary of China-Pakistan diplomatic ties.

On behalf of the Pakistani government and people, Shah Mahmood Qureshi expressed gratitude to the Chinese government for its decision to provide vaccine aid and procurement facilitation to Pakistan. He said Pakistan has approved a vaccine by China's Sinopharm for emergency use and will actively consider granting market access to other China-developed vaccines. He also suggested the two sides strengthen communication to ensure successful celebrations of the 70th anniversary of the bilateral ties and hold the 10th CPEC Joint Cooperation Committee meeting at an early date, so as to push for greater progress in bilateral relations.

Riaz Haq said...

Tears and safety fears as #India huge #coronavirus #vaccine campaign falters. Motivated by vaccine nationalism, #Indian made #Covaxin vaccine was hastily approved by #Modi government without completing phase 3 trials - World - DAWN.COM

https://www.dawn.com/news/1603362

India's huge coronavirus vaccination drive is behind schedule, with a third of recipients not showing up for appointments because of safety fears, technical glitches and a belief that the pandemic is ending.

After one week, India has vaccinated 1.4 million people, or 200,000 people per day. It had initially hoped to process 300,000 per day before ramping up the rollout and inoculating 300m by July.

At the Sharda Hospital in Greater Noida near New Delhi, pharma student Khushi Dhingra, 17, hugged a friend and wept as she waited to get her shot.

“I am very afraid. I hate needles and I am worried about side effects,” she told AFP.


“My papa is very worried too. He is calling me again and again to make sure I am okay.”

“There are about 80 students in my batch but only two have opted to get the shot,” said nursing student Sakshi Sharma, 21, in Greater Noida.

“My friends are saying there will be side effects, that you can even get paralysis.”

India is using two shots for its drive.

One is Covishield, a locally produced version of the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine, which has been approved and safely used in a number of other countries after completing Phase 3 human trials.

The other — Covaxin — was developed locally by Bharat Biotech and has not yet completed Phase 3 trials, though the government has insisted it is “110 per cent safe”.

WhatsApp worries
Side effects are a common fear, with a few cases of severe reactions — and even deaths — reported widely in the media and circulating wildly on Facebook and WhatsApp.

In the eastern state of West Bengal, health chief Ajoy Chakraborty said that turnout was just under 70pc, calling it “not encouraging”.

“We could have achieved our target if some hadn't backed out after seeing television reports of adverse effects following immunisation,” Chakraborty said.

But Alisha Khan, 20, a nursing student in Greater Noida, said people were also hesitant because of the “rushed” approval of Covaxin.

“Why are they trying to experiment on us? First, they should have completed trials in a proper way,” Khan told AFP. “I am shivering already out of fear.”

Coronavirus complacency
Dhingra, in the end, did not get a shot after staff realised she was under 18. She had, however, received a text telling her to come for the vaccination from the IT system managing the mammoth process.

The government says that this and other glitches are being ironed out.

One was that if a person did not show up for vaccination, someone else could not simply take their place.

This led to unfinished vaccine vials — which contain a certain number of doses and have to be used that day — being thrown away.

Also hurting the effort is complacency with the number of coronavirus infections and deaths in India falling sharply in recent months.

“In the beginning when there was lockdown, [villagers] were very scared of the coronavirus,” said Asha Chauhan, 30, who is part of vaccination efforts in rural areas.

“Now that fear has gone because cases have come down. They feel corona has gone from our country now,” she said. “They fear they will die if they take the vaccine.”

Selfie zones
Many of the 30m people due for jabs in the first phase are health workers who have seen the deadly pandemic close up — yet many of them are hesitant.

This needs to addressed before the vaccine is rolled out to the wider Indian population, experts say, where vaccine scepticism is already rife.

“They must launch awareness campaigns in every nook and corner of the country,” Anita Yadav, 25, an auxiliary nurse and midwife, told AFP.

The government has attempted to boost participation, even adapting a classic Bollywood song with lyrics telling people not to believe false rumours.

Riaz Haq said...

If Poor Countries Go Unvaccinated, a Study Says, Rich Countries & Global #Economy Will Be Hurt. Sharing #Covid_19 #vaccine with poor nations is not an act of charity. Study says it is in rich countries' self-interest to do so. #Covid_19 #CovidVaccine https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/23/business/coronavirus-vaccines-global-economy.html?smid=tw-share

A failure to distribute the Covid-19 vaccine in poor nations will worsen economic damage, with half the costs borne by wealthy countries, new research shows.

This is the crucial takeaway from an academic study to be released on Monday. In the most extreme scenario — with wealthy nations fully vaccinated by the middle of this year, and poor countries largely shut out — the study concludes that the global economy would suffer losses exceeding $9 trillion, a sum greater than the annual output of Japan and Germany combined.

Nearly half of those costs would be absorbed by wealthy countries like the United States, Canada and Britain.

In the scenario that researchers term most likely, in which developing countries vaccinate half their populations by the end of the year, the world economy would still absorb a blow of between $1.8 trillion and $3.8 trillion. More than half of the pain would be concentrated in wealthy countries.