Both the American and the Iranian delegations are expected to begin peace talks in Islamabad tomorrow after the announcement of the Pakistan-brokered ceasefire. The US team is led by Vice President J.D. Vance and includes President Trump's envoy Steve Witkoff and the president's son-in-law Jared Kushner. The Iranian team includes Parliament Speaker Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf and Foreign Minister Abbas Aragchi. Mohammad Ghalibaf is a former IRGC (Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps) commander with close ties to the hardliners.
The Islamabad meeting has come as a result of the tireless efforts of the Pakistani leaders to stop the war since it started on February 28 with the US-Israeli attack on Iran. But these efforts took on special urgency on the morning of April 7, when President Donald Trump posted an ominous warning on Truth Social: "A Whole Civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again". "We will find out tonight, one of the most important moments in the long and complex history of the world", Trump added. The ultimatum to Iran sent shockwaves around the world because it is a fact that the president of the United States controls one of the largest stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction (WMD). The post came out at 8 AM US East Coast time when it was 8 PM in Islamabad. Immediately, Pakistan's Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and Field Marshal Asim Munir stepped up their frantic efforts to save the world as Trump's deadline approached. The world heaved a sigh of relief when, about an hour before Trump's deadline, the US president acknowledged and positively responded to a Pakistani proposal to accept a two-week ceasefire which was also approved by the Iranian leadership. The oil price dropped and the stock markets rallied in the hope of a permanent end to hostilities.
 |
| President Trump's Post Accepting Ceasefire with Iran |
After the ceasefire announcement two days ago, Pakistani leaders have organized a US-Iran meeting scheduled for Saturday in Islamabad. JD Vance, the Vice President of the United States is traveling to Pakistan to lead the US delegation for talks with Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Aragchi.
 |
| Iran's 10-Point Proposal For Peace |
Iran's 10-point proposal that Trump referred to in his post as the basis of US-Iran talks includes the following:
1. Guarantee that Iran will not be attacked again.
2. Permanent end to war, not just a ceasefire.
3. End to Israeli attacks in Lebanon.
4. Lifting of all US sanctions on Iran.
5. End to all regional fighting against Iranian allies.
6. Iran would reopen the Strait of Hormuz
7. Iran would impose a $2 million fee per ship transiting Hormuz.
8. Iran would split these fees with Oman.
9. Iran would establish rules for safe passage through Hormuz.
10. Iran would use Hormuz fees for reconstruction instead of reparations.
 |
| Europeans and Japanese Leaders Thank You Letter to Pakistan |
These are high-stakes negotiations that could fail but just the fact that the two sides have agreed to talk gives the world some hope of a better outcome. Meanwhile, many world leaders have thanked the Pakistani leaders for stepping up at a crucial time. But many in Pakistan's neighboring country of India are very unhappy about Pakistan's role in it. For example, Indian Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar has derided Pakistan as a "dalal" (pimp) country. He is clearly unhappy that his country's campaign to isolate Pakistan has backfired. In fact, Pakistan's geopolitical profile has particularly risen after the country's robust response to what the Indian Prime Minister called "Operation Sindoor" which he launched against Pakistan last year in May.
Related Links:
Haq's Musings
South Asia Investor Review
Pakistan Downs India's French Rafale Jets in a Major Aerial Battle
Has Modi Succeeded Diplomatically or Militarily Against Pakistan After Pahalgam?
Trump Administration Seeks Pakistan's Help in Stabilizing the Middle East
Indian Military Begins to Accept its Losses to Pakistan in "Operation Sindoor"
Has Modi Succeeded Militarily or Diplomatically in Isolating Pakistan After "Operation Sindoor"?
West's Technological Edge in Geopolitical Competition
Modi's India: A Paper Elephant?
Pahalgam Attack: Why is the Indian Media Not Asking Hard Questions?
Ukraine's Lesson For Pakistan: Never Give Up Nukes!
Saudi-Pakistan Joint Defense Deal
Pakistan's Sea-Based Second Strike Capability
Riaz Haq Youtube Channel
VPOS Youtube Channel
Very well written.
ReplyDeleteI think two events diminished any leverage India might have had:
1. India losing both militarily and reputation wise in the May 2025 short battle with Pakistan.
2. India establishing a close and strategic relationship with Israel, culminating in Modi’s visit to Israel. This immediately made India a non trustworthy country in the eyes of Iran.
India never spoke a word of condemnation against the US-Israel attack on Iran. Thus India squandered considerable goodwill it had created for itself in Iran over decades.
India could not offer mediation in this dispute as it had itself refused to acknowledge mediation by Trump in stopping the India Pakistan battle.
Jaishankar is in the slammer, the dog house.
In the wrong place at the wrong time!
Would Trump discard the whole world's appeals and listen to Sharifay ?
ReplyDeletehttps://youtu.be/dyj0ZVhG1AE?si=9fxExogPYQT4Z902
Shams: Would Trump discard the whole world's appeals and listen to Sharifay ?
ReplyDeleteThere are many in the world, including one of our neighbors, who want to deny credit to Pakistan for anything! I’d rather pay attention to who the Iranians themselves are giving credit to.
X post by Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Aragchi thanking Shehbaz Sharif:
https://x.com/araghchi/status/2041655156215799821?s=20
On behalf of the Islamic Republic of Iran, I express gratitude and appreciation for my dear brothers HE Prime Minister of Pakistan Sharif and HE Field Marshal Munir for their tireless efforts to end the war
in the region. In response to the brotherly request of PM Sharif in his tweet, and considering the request by the U.S. for negotiations based on its 15-point proposal as well as announcement by POTUS about acceptance of the general framework of Iran's 10-point proposal as a basis for negotiations, I hereby declare on behalf of
Iran's Supreme National Security Council: If attacks against Iran are halted, our Powerful Armed
Forces will cease their defensive operations. For a period of two weeks, safe passage through the Strait of Hormuz will be possible via coordination with Iran's Armed Forces and with due consideration of
technical limitations.
Seyed Abbas Araghchi Minister of Foreign Affairs
Islamic Republic of Iran
Atif Mian
ReplyDelete@AtifRMian
How Pakistan made the world over 3 trillion dollars richer
On April 7, the world edged toward Trump's 8pm ultimatum that "a whole civilization will die tonight." By mid-afternoon, Polymarket gave less than a 5% chance for a ceasefire. But then in a flurry of last-minute diplomacy led by Pakistan's PM Shehbaz Sharif, ceasefire odds shifted from near-impossibility to 100%, as both U.S. and Iranian leadership publicly acknowledged the important role played by Pakistan.
The sharp shift in probability of ceasefire from near-zero to certainty, allows us to estimate cleanly the market value of Pakistan's successful diplomacy. There was a sharp jump of 2.9% in S&P500 around the ceasefire announcement. The reaction was similar the world over.
Global markets represent about $125T, so a 2.9% jump represents a gain of 3.6 trillion dollars for the world. Pakistan helped create TEN times its own GDP for the world!
For me, the best part is not the trillions of dollar, but seeing Pakistan on the world stage as a peace maker.
I hope Pakistan runs with this new identity by promoting peace not only abroad, but also at home. That means moving away from politics of division and exclusion, and treating every citizen as its own.
A beautiful view of Pakistan’s capital. The violet ones are Jacaranda trees in #Islamabad, the host city of #US-#Iran peace talks in #Pakistan. These trees bloom during late spring & early summer (April to June), transforming streets and parks into scenic, violet-carpeted landscapes. These trees thrive in the city's climate, creating a picturesque, serene environment that draws visitors.
ReplyDeletehttps://x.com/haqsmusings/status/2042981577295081704?s=46&t=Uy6jyUH6DlEyIPi6Mq6AGQ
I love those trees! They grow in Pretoria and Johannesburg as well.
ReplyDeleteSpring is always a beautiful site with the purple Jacarandas showing off their splendor
I have seen Jacaranda trees in full splendor in São Paulo and Rio twice, in 2010 and 2012. Brazil is an amazing country.
ReplyDeletePunit Pania
ReplyDelete@Punit_Pania
It's so embarrassing to see Godi Media still trying ridicule Pakistan's role in the ceasefire talks. Sometimes, it's better to shut up than expose your desperation.
https://x.com/Punit_Pania/status/2042530307451293930?s=20
---------------
Punit Pania
@Punit_Pania
No mugshots of Islam Hruday Samrat MunirBhai or Mananiya Pujaniya Shehbaz Dada on the hoardings. Pakistan could learn so much from our megalomaniac leaders and their mob of sycophants.
https://x.com/Punit_Pania/status/2043096039780159657?s=20
--------------------
Ashok Swain
@ashoswai
I am not a fan of Munir or Sharif. But, the way they are playing the role as hosts of Islamabad talks, meeting & greeting the foreign leaders with grace & dignified manner, it will make any Pakistani happy. No jumping, no hugging, no Khi Khi like their Indian counterpart, Modi.
https://x.com/ashoswai/status/2042917355357921310?s=20
India cracks down on satirists for turning its prime minister into a punch line
ReplyDeletehttps://www.npr.org/2026/04/11/g-s1-116582/india-cracks-down-satirists-turning-prime-minister-punch-line-modi
MUMBAI, India — For years, supporters of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi carefully cultivated his public image as a strongman and hard taskmaster — a leader who puts in 18‑hour days to propel India toward superpower status.
To illustrate India's rise, they tout Modi's rapport with other world leaders — like when he met with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in late February. Modi was generous with his signature hugs and laughs, and Netanyahu effusive with praise for his "great friend."
Yet three days after their meeting, Israel and the U.S. launched their war on Iran, sending India's currency and stock market tumbling. Iran also restricted the movement of fuel ships in the Strait of Hormuz, forcing Indians to scramble for cooking gas and shuttering many restaurants and factories.
The Indian government, led by Modi, appeared to be caught off guard by the conflict.
And then, the memes began.
Indian satirists, cartoonists and comedians flocked to X, Instagram and Facebook to mock Modi.
Cartoonist Satish Acharya drew Modi wearing a gag and shutting his eyes to news about the war. Instagram user Namaskaar reworked a popular hymn to appeal to Modi to use his friendship with Netanyahu to resolve India's fuel crunch. Comedian Pulkit Mani performed a sharp mimicry of Modi's exuberance and awkward hugs while meeting world leaders.
Indian censors are also watching.
Several accounts and posts, including those of Acharya and Mani, were withheld in India. In emails shared by dozens of users, host platforms X and Meta claimed they were doing this as per legal requests by Indian authorities.
The blocked accounts include those belonging to popular independent journalists and satirists with hundreds of thousands of followers, and even one legislator from the opposition Trinamool Congress party.
"It's really stuff that's critical of the government," says Prateek Waghre, an internet policy researcher with Tech Global Institute. He says the orders often come from both the police and the federal ministry, and in most cases, users aren't told why their content is being blocked.
https://x.com/sagarikaghose/status/2035910587658727761?s=20
A three-hour takedown deadline
Policy experts say such rapid takedown orders are possible because India last year tightened an existing law requiring social media companies to remove posts flagged as illegal by authorities, and shortened the compliance window from 36 hours to just three. A new set of rules proposed by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology now goes even further, seeking to restrict creators themselves while making platforms directly accountable for the content they host.
The ministry, X and Meta did not respond to NPR's request for comment or agree to an interview.
India's content takedown regime is "the most aggressive timeline for any jurisdiction in the world," says Akash Karmakar, a New Delhi-based lawyer who specializes in technology law. A three-hour takedown deadline leaves it open to misuse, he says. And while users can challenge the orders in Indian high courts, "the chances of you being able to get a court reprieve to even the most perverse order in a matter of three hours is 0.00%," he adds.
That's what happened to Prateek Sharma, who runs the satirical account Dr Nimo Yadav on X.
In March, X emailed him in the middle of the night, saying the Indian authorities had asked the platform to block his account. When the high court heard his challenge days later, a government counsel defended the government's request, saying the posts portrayed Modi in "bad taste."
Like when Sharma wrote, "Elect a clown, expect a circus."
On Monday, the Delhi High Court directed X to reinstate his account, while keeping the specific posts cited in the initial order blocked.
Last I heard,
ReplyDelete"US and Iran fail to reach agreement after historic peace talks in Pakistan, Vance says"
https://www.bbc.com/news/live/cn4v0xm9y0kt?post=asset%3A210297c5-bd23-418b-9870-30a760758dc5#post
But regardless of the outcome of the talks I would still appreciate the efforts and proactiveness shown by Pakistan in bringing the warring parties to the negotiating table since an escalation or continuation of this war is in nobody's interest (except the Israelis perhaps).
And I would also acknowledge that Jaishankar's comments on Pakistan's involvement was rather undiplomatic and crass considering that a speedy conclusion to the conflict (or a ceasefire atleast) is in India's interest as well. I expected better from a Foreign Minister and a career diplomat. Instead of the comments he made, he could have said something more diplomatic to explain why India isn't trying to mediate despite the economic repercussions of the war at home.
That said, its plainly obvious that for Pakistan the stakes in this conflict were always higher than for India due to geography and its geo-political situation - a shared border with Iran, the situation on its northern and eastern borders, and the implications of Saudi-Pakistan defense pact. Had the Iran war escalated into a direct confrontation between Iran and the Gulf Arab states - especially Saudi Arabia - Pakistan would have found itself in an uneviable position of having to pick sides due to the defense pact. And that would have meant a state of conflict on THREE of its borders. So, Pakistan *had* to intervene, if only for the sake of its own national security interests. And the fact that Pakistan has more cosy relations with the Trump administration than India would have been an added inducement to play the mediator as well.
On the other hand, despite the economic impact that an escalation in Iran war would have at home, India wouldn't have wanted to go anywhere near this powderkeg due to the Trump factor alone. Even if US and Iran were to reach some kind of agreement today to halt the war, Trump in his next mood swing might choose to tear it to shreds once again and bomb Iran regardless tommorrow.